Less than a month after “Apollo 13” opened in movie theaters in June 1995, then-President Bill Clinton met with mission commander Jim Lovell to present one of the highest awards an astronaut can receive — the Congressional Space Medal of Honor (opens in new tab).
Joined in the Oval Office by former medal recipients Charles “Pete” Conrad and U.S. Sen. John Glenn (D-Ohio), as well as by Tom Hanks, who portrayed Lovell in the hit film, Clinton noted that because of the movie Americans now knew why Lovell was deserving of praise more so than they did in the 25 years that had passed since the ill-fated Apollo 13 mission made it safely back (opens in new tab) to Earth in 1970.
“While you may have lost the moon,” Clinton said to Lovell, “but you gained something perhaps far more important, the abiding respect and gratitude of the American people.”
As the President draped the medal over Lovell’s head, watching the ceremony from off to the side was Lori Garver. Then the executive director of the National Space Society (NSS), a nonprofit organization championing the creation of a spacefaring civilization, Garver had not only been instrumental in arranging for the medal to be awarded to Lovell (opens in new tab), but, as only a few people knew at the time, she also helped save the event from being canceled the night before.
Apollo 13: Facts about NASA’s near-disaster moon mission
Garver, who went on to become deputy administrator of NASA, recalls the events of July 26, 1995 for the first time in her new book, “Escaping Gravity: My Quest to Transform NASA and Launch a New Space Age (opens in new tab),” released by Diversion Books on Tuesday (June 21).
Failure is not an option
By all measures, Jim Lovell should have been among the first group of astronauts to receive the Congressional Space Medal of Honor when it was first bestowed in October 1978. Among the six chosen were Alan Shepard, the first American to fly into space; Glenn, the first American to orbit Earth; the late Virgil “Gus” Grissom, commander of the ill-fated Apollo 1 crew; Frank Borman, Lovell’s commander on Apollo 8, the first mission to orbit the moon; Neil Armstrong, the first person to walk on the moon; and Conrad, commander of the first crew to live on board the United States’ first space station, Skylab.
Lovell believed that he was overlooked because of how Apollo 13 was perceived by NASA prior to the movie being made.
“Jim Lovell expressed his disappointment during dinner that he had never received the Congressional Space Medal of Honor,” wrote Garver, recounting an event that brought together the real Apollo 13 astronauts with the actors portraying them before the movie began filming. “The comment was made in passing, while he was explaining to the table that at the time of Apollo 13, the mission was considered a failure and NASA had done its best to sweep it under the rug.”
Hearing this, Hanks caught Garver’s eye “and we both silently acknowledged the mention,” Garver recalled.
Later that evening, Hanks pulled Garver aside and said if she was able to arrange for the medal for Lovell, he would like to be there to see it awarded. Garver immediately built upon Hanks’ interest, getting the actor to agree that if the White House ceremony came together, he would then speak at an event on Capitol Hill, lending his support to the International Space Station project. (Assembly of the ISS didn’t begin until 1998.)
“It was an opportunity [neither NASA nor the White House] could pass up,” Garver wrote. “After months of coordinating logistics, the ceremony was scheduled.”
That is, up until the night before, after Hanks had flown in and just before a private dinner was set to begin in Lovell’s honor. The White House informed Garver that the ceremony would have to be rescheduled for a later date.
“I was told, ‘It doesn’t fit the message of the day,’ wrote Garver.
No one, though, had told the president that.
After Garver shared the situation with another of the dinner’s guests, Barbara Mikulski, the high-ranking senator from Maryland happened to receive a call from the White House. Soon after she came back to the dinner table another call came in, this time for Lovell.
The Apollo program: How NASA sent astronauts to the moon
“He returned with a huge grin and news that the medal ceremony was back on the schedule for the following day,” Garver recalled. “Senator Mikulski told me later in the evening that the president had called to talk to her about the escalating situation in Bosnia, and after that discussion, she mentioned that her dinner companions, Jim Lovell and Tom Hanks (opens in new tab), were sorry they wouldn’t be seeing him the next day. The president claimed to have been unaware of the planned ceremony or the last-minute change and, as she relayed it to me, didn’t seem very happy with the decision.”
The next day, Lovell became only the ninth astronaut to receive the Congressional Space Medal of Honor.
“I humbly accept this medal as commander of Apollo 13 but with the understanding really that it was the efforts and the intuition and the teamwork of my crewmates Jack Swigert and Fred Haise (opens in new tab) and the hundreds of people within NASA and the contractor group that really worked hard to make … [Apollo 13] a successful recovery,” Lovell said.
Houston, we’ve had a problem
Although Garver kept the behind-the-scenes details private until writing “Escaping Gravity,” Lovell was aware of her role.
“In looking at all my stuff while researching the book, I came across a note he sent me a week after thanking me for my help in making this happen,” Garver said in an interview with collectSPACE.com. “He said in the note that he knew it was me/Tom Hanks/Senator Mikulski who helped because NASA had tried this before and not gotten it through the White House. So he knew there were other priorities at work.”
For Garver, the experience was rewarding, but also strengthened her approach as to how to motivate people in the direction desired.
“Human nature is something that is just inherent in all decisions, so in my career I have always kept in mind what are the incentives, the human interests, in what we’re trying to get done and how do you maximize those to get the decisions that you want. Not in any sort of underhanded way, but just out front,” she said. “I mean, brilliant people like to be around other brilliant people.”
Sometimes, though, those same people find themselves on the opposite ends of a decision. Much of “Escaping Gravity” is Garver recounting her leadership role in transitioning NASA from being entirely reliant on the contractor group that Lovell thanked in his medal of honor speech to embracing competition and what is now a burgeoning commercial space industry.
Unfortunately for Garver, Lovell and some of his fellow Apollo-era astronauts were not convinced that the commercial spaceflight providers were up for the challenge. In public statements and in testimony delivered to Congress, Lovell, Armstrong and Apollo 17 commander Gene Cernan voiced their objections to changing the way in which NASA contracted for its rockets and spacecraft.
“When I heard it was happening, I said to Charlie [Bolden, then-NASA administrator], ‘Can we please offer them a briefing? I think if they understood it, they wouldn’t feel this way,'” Garver said. “This was the hardest part of the book [to write]. I was deputy, and the person who was leading the agency was not initially on board.”
“I think it was what kept us from being able to brief them and that is a perfect example of how it was made harder,” said Garver. “I mean, if those things had been different, everything could have been different.”
Who will that be?
As Garver wrote in “Escaping Gravity,” with the rise of commercial spaceflight has come the opportunity for an expanded population to become astronauts (opens in new tab). What that title means, though, may change.
“As more and more people travel to and through space, the mystique of the astronauts will eventually recede,” she wrote. “Titles don’t typically signify sameness. Sailors can traverse vast oceans or small lakes, and doctors don’t all operate on people.”
— Apollo 13 timeline: The hectic days of NASA’s ‘successful failure’ to the moon
— Apollo 13 at 50: How NASA turned near-disaster at the moon into a ‘successful failure’ in space
— Failure was not an option: NASA’s Apollo 13 mission of survival in pictures
In the 27 years since Lovell was presented with the Congressional Space Medal of Honor, 19 more astronauts have been similarly awarded (opens in new tab), bringing the total to 28. The most recent medal was bestowed by President George W. Bush to the space shuttle’s first pilot, Bob Crippen, in 2006.
“It used to always be firsts,” Garver told collectSPACE. “Given that criteria, it seems certainly like Doug Hurley [should be honored], for the first to command a new spacecraft.”
Hurley, together with fellow NASA astronaut Bob Behnken, flew on SpaceX’s first Crew Dragon to carry astronauts (opens in new tab) into space in 2020.
“But for me, I would honor the Inspiration4 crew. That’s what I would do,” Garver said, referring to the first privately-funded “all-civilian” crew (opens in new tab) to fly into Earth orbit in 2021. “It represents such a tremendous transition, and I just couldn’t believe how quickly it happened. From when we flew the first Dragon under a NASA contract to having one go with four non-NASA employees and be the first crew with gender equality. If we are going to keep honoring these brave heroes, then that was pretty brave.”